NY Debt Collection & Judgment Enforcement FAQ | Aryeh Law Group
CALL WHATSAPP FREE CONSULT
WHATSAPP US
Aryeh Law Group PLLC
Mon – Fri: 9:00 am – 5:00 pm· 555 Willow Ave, Cedarhurst NY
Aryeh Law Group PLLC
(646) 276-7070 FREE CONSULTATION
YOUR CASE · FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

Straight answers, before you pick up the phone.

Detailed answers to the questions clients ask most — collecting commercial debts, enforcing judgments under CPLR Article 52, business litigation, and defending a lawsuit in New York and New Jersey.

General information about New York and New Jersey law — not legal advice about your situation. Deadlines and outcomes turn on specific facts; when in doubt, ask.

COLLECTING A DEBT ENFORCING A JUDGMENT BUSINESS DISPUTES IF YOU'VE BEEN SUED WORKING WITH THE FIRM
01 · COLLECTING WHAT YOU'RE OWED

Commercial collections.

How does a commercial collections case actually work?+

Typically four stages: attorney demand → lawsuit → judgment → enforcement. A meaningful share of commercial debts resolves at the demand stage — a letter from litigation counsel changes the debtor's math, because ignoring it now has a price.

When it doesn't resolve, suit is filed. If the debt rests on a promissory note, guaranty, or another instrument for the payment of money only, New York's CPLR 3213 permits summary judgment in lieu of complaint — a fast track that can produce a judgment in months rather than years. Every matter is run with the end in mind: collection, not just a piece of paper.

How long do I have to sue over an unpaid invoice, loan, or contract?+

In New York, most contract claims must be brought within six years of the breach (CPLR 213). Contracts for the sale of goods are generally four years under the Uniform Commercial Code. New Jersey's limit for most contract claims is also six years.

Practically, sooner is stronger. Witnesses fade and records scatter — but most importantly, the debtor's assets deteriorate. The best time to move on a receivable is while there is still something to collect from.

Can I recover interest and my attorney's fees?+

Interest — generally yes. New York adds prejudgment interest on contract claims at 9% per year, running from the breach (CPLR 5001, 5004). On a debt that has aged a few years, that is real money on top of the principal.

Attorney's fees — only if your paperwork provides for them. New York follows the American Rule: each side bears its own fees unless a contract or statute shifts them. If your invoices, credit applications, or contracts contain a fee-shifting clause, fees are usually recoverable from the debtor. If they don't, the firm can fix your documents going forward so the next collection is on the debtor's dime.

The debtor is a shell LLC — or says the business is empty. Is the debt dead?+

Not necessarily. Four avenues get examined before anyone gives up: personal guaranties (often sitting overlooked in the credit file), fraudulent-transfer claims under New York's Debtor and Creditor Law where assets were shifted to a successor entity or insiders — generally reachable within a four-year lookback — successor liability where the "new" business is the old one in different clothes, and in the right circumstances piercing the corporate veil.

This is exactly why the firm assesses collectability before you spend anything: an honest read on whether the case ends with money moving.

Should I check whether the debtor has assets before suing?+

Yes — and the firm does it as a matter of course. There is no point spending fees on a judgment that cannot be collected. Before recommending suit, the firm evaluates what is publicly and lawfully discoverable about the debtor: real property, corporate filings, UCC liens, prior judgments, and litigation history.

Full financial disclosure under oath only becomes compellable after judgment — which is exactly why the pre-suit read is an experience call, and why an honest one up front is worth more than an optimistic one.

How is a collections law firm different from a collection agency?+

A collection agency can call and write. It cannot sue, restrain a bank account, levy, garnish wages, or examine a debtor under oath — only a law firm can invoke the court’s enforcement machinery. Agencies typically move on when a debtor refuses to engage; that is precisely the moment litigation counsel becomes effective.

The practical difference shows in debtor behavior: a demand that can visibly be followed by a lawsuit changes the debtor’s calculation in a way a fourth collection letter never will.

Will I personally have to go to court?+

Usually not. Most commercial collection matters resolve through counsel — demand, negotiation, or motion practice — without the client ever setting foot in a courtroom. If testimony is ever needed you'll be fully prepared, but the strategy is to build enough leverage that the debtor writes a check, not to put you on a witness stand.

02 · ENFORCING A JUDGMENT

Judgment enforcement under CPLR Article 52.

I won my case. Why isn't the money in my account?+

Because a judgment is a piece of paper — the court does not collect it for you. New York gives judgment creditors one of the most powerful enforcement toolkits in the country under CPLR Article 52, but every tool has to be aimed at real, located assets. Enforcement is a discipline of its own, and it is the core of this firm's practice.

What can actually be done to a judgment debtor in New York?+

The Article 52 toolkit, in rough order of use:

Restraining notice (CPLR 5222) — freezes the debtor's bank accounts up to twice the judgment amount the moment the bank receives it. No court appearance needed.

Information subpoenas (CPLR 5224) — compel banks, employers, and the debtor to disclose assets under oath.

Executions (CPLR 5230, 5232) — the sheriff or marshal levies on bank accounts, receivables, and personal property.

Income execution (CPLR 5231) — garnishes up to 10% of the debtor's gross wages.

Turnover proceedings (CPLR 5225) — a special proceeding compelling the debtor, or a third party holding the debtor's assets, to hand them over.

Ignoring these devices is not a strategy — noncompliance carries contempt exposure.

How long is my judgment good for?+

New York money judgments are generally enforceable for twenty years (CPLR 211(b)). A docketed judgment is a lien on the debtor's real property in that county for ten years, and the lien can be renewed (CPLR 5014).

And the judgment grows while it sits: post-judgment interest accrues at 9% per year on most commercial judgments. A judgment in a drawer is not a dead asset — it is an appreciating one that nobody is collecting.

My judgment is from New Jersey or another state. Can it be enforced here?+

Yes. A sister-state judgment is domesticated in New York under CPLR Article 54 (or by an action on the judgment), and once docketed here the full Article 52 toolkit applies as if it were a New York judgment. Judgments from foreign countries have their own recognition procedure under Article 53.

It works in both directions: because the firm is admitted in New York and New Jersey, a New York judgment can be docketed and pursued against the debtor's New Jersey assets without handing the file to a second firm.

The debtor moved assets to a spouse or a new company. Now what?+

Transfers made to defeat creditors can be unwound. New York's voidable-transactions law (Debtor and Creditor Law, Article 10) lets a judgment creditor claw back transfers made with intent to hinder collection, or made without fair value while the debtor was insolvent — generally reachable within a four-year window. The Article 52 discovery devices are how those transfers get found: bank subpoenas, deposition of the debtor, and document demands that map where the money went.

What happens if the debtor just ignores subpoenas and court orders?+

That stops being a strategy quickly. Disobedience of a restraining notice, information subpoena, or turnover order is punishable as contempt of court (CPLR 5251) — exposing the debtor to fines, adverse orders, and in persistent cases arrest on a warrant. Debtors who stonewall often convert a money problem into a personal-liberty problem, and their lawyers know it. Pressing noncompliance is frequently what brings a silent debtor to the table.

Can the debtor’s real estate be reached?+

Yes. Docketing the judgment with the county clerk creates a lien on the debtor’s real property in that county — including property acquired while the lien is in force (CPLR 5203). The lien means the debtor generally cannot sell or refinance without dealing with you.

Where warranted, enforcement goes further: execution and sheriff’s sale of non-exempt real property (CPLR 5236), or appointment of a receiver to manage or sell an asset (CPLR 5228). Real property is often the leverage that resolves a judgment that bank levies alone could not.

What if the debtor files for bankruptcy?+

A bankruptcy filing triggers the automatic stay, which immediately halts enforcement. But bankruptcy is not always the end: the firm files and defends the claim in the case, and debts arising from fraud or similar misconduct may be challenged as nondischargeable.

Bankruptcy also cuts the other way — it is expensive, public, and puts the debtor’s entire financial life under a trustee’s microscope. Many debtors who threaten bankruptcy never file, and the threat is weighed accordingly.

The debtor is "judgment-proof" today. Is the case over?+

No — it is on a clock that favors you. The judgment lives for twenty years, interest compounds the debtor’s problem at 9% a year, and a docketed lien reaches real property the debtor acquires later. People’s circumstances change: new jobs, inheritances, property, businesses. Judgments are monitored and re-run against the debtor’s circumstances periodically, so the day the debtor stops being judgment-proof is the day enforcement resumes.

Can I settle my judgment for less — or sell it?+

Both. A negotiated discount for an immediate lump sum is often the rational endgame, especially against a debtor with limited reachable assets. Payment plans are papered with an affidavit of confession of judgment or default-judgment stipulation so a missed payment restores full enforcement instantly.

Judgments are also assignable — they can be sold or transferred. Whether selling at a discount beats enforcing depends on the asset picture, which the firm assesses before recommending either.

Is any money off-limits?+

Yes — and a legitimate enforcement practice respects it. Social Security, SSI, public assistance, most pension and retirement income, and a statutorily protected baseline amount in bank accounts holding exempt funds cannot be taken, and wage garnishment is capped by statute. Strategy is built around the debtor's reachable assets from day one, which is also why the collectability assessment happens before you commit.

03 · BUSINESS DISPUTES

Commercial litigation.

What kinds of disputes does the firm litigate?+

Breach of contract, unpaid notes and guaranties, vendor and supplier disputes, partnership and shareholder conflicts, business torts — fraud, conversion, tortious interference — and disputes arising from commercial transactions and receivables. If the matter is fundamentally about money owed between businesses or business people, it is in the firm's lane.

What does a lawsuit look like, start to finish?+

Pleadings (complaint and answer) → discovery (documents and depositions) → motion practice (often summary judgment) → trial, for the small fraction of cases that get there. Timelines run from a few months — where CPLR 3213 or early motion practice applies — to a few years for a heavily contested case.

Most commercial cases resolve before trial. Good litigation treats every stage as leverage: the question is never just "can we win," but "when does the other side's cost of continuing exceed the cost of paying."

Where would my case be filed?+

Wherever venue and the amount in controversy put it. In New York: Supreme Court in the appropriate county — Nassau, Kings, Queens, New York — with larger commercial matters eligible for the Commercial Division; smaller claims belong in District Court or the New York City Civil Court. In New Jersey: Superior Court, Law Division, or the Special Civil Part for claims up to $20,000. The firm appears in all of them.

Most cases settle. What makes a settlement actually stick?+

Paper with teeth. A payment plan is only as good as what happens when it's breached — so settlements are structured with an affidavit of confession of judgment (CPLR 3218) or a stipulation providing for immediate entry of judgment on default. One missed payment converts the promise into an enforceable judgment without relitigating anything. That is the difference between a settlement and a collectable obligation.

04 · IF YOU'VE BEEN SUED

Defense of businesses and individuals.

I was just served with a lawsuit. What's my deadline?+

In New York, generally 20 days to appear if the papers were handed to you personally, and 30 days from completion of service by other methods (CPLR 320). In New Jersey, generally 35 days.

Miss the deadline and the plaintiff can move for a default judgment — which is how people discover a frozen bank account months later. The single most important thing to do after being served is call counsel that week. Deadlines drive everything else.

A default judgment was entered against me. Is it final?+

Often not. New York gives two main routes back in: CPLR 5015(a)(1) — vacate for excusable default plus a meritorious defense, generally within one year — and CPLR 317 — for a defendant who was not served by personal delivery and did not receive actual notice in time to defend, within one year of learning of the judgment (and no more than five years from entry).

If service was defective, the judgment may be void outright, tested at a traverse hearing. Timing matters enormously here: courts hold delay against the moving party, so move the moment you learn of it.

My bank account was frozen out of nowhere. What happened?+

Almost certainly a restraining notice or levy on a judgment — sometimes one entered years ago that you never knew existed. The playbook: identify the judgment, check how you were served, claim any statutory exemptions for protected funds, and either move to vacate (if the judgment is vulnerable) or negotiate a release and resolution from an informed position.

What not to do: start moving money between accounts. It complicates exemption claims and can create fraudulent-transfer exposure. Get counsel first.

What defenses might I have?+

It depends on the case, but the recurring ones: defective service or lack of personal jurisdiction, an expired statute of limitations, payment or setoff, disputed amounts or performance, and counterclaims that change the settlement math. Claims built on purchased or stale debt frequently have proof problems — standing, chain of title, admissible account records — that only surface when someone actually litigates the defense instead of folding.

Will a judgment against me show up on my credit report?+

Since 2017, civil judgments generally no longer appear on consumer credit reports. But that is not the same as invisible: a judgment is a public court record, surfaces in background and lender searches, and once docketed becomes a lien that blocks selling or refinancing real property until it is dealt with. The practical consequences usually arrive at the worst time — a closing — which is a reason to resolve a judgment on your terms rather than discover it on the title report.

Should I just settle?+

Sometimes — but from strength, after the weaknesses in the plaintiff's case are on the table. An early, informed settlement at a real discount with clean releases can beat years of fees and uncertainty. What you should never do is ignore the case or sign the first stipulation put in front of you; both convert a defensible position into a judgment.

05 · WORKING WITH THE FIRM

Fees, process, and fit.

What does it cost?+

The consultation is free. Most collections and judgment-enforcement matters are handled with no upfront cost to you — the fee comes from what is actually recovered, so the firm's incentive is identical to yours. Litigation and defense engagements are structured in writing at the consultation, before any work begins, so there are no surprises.

Who actually handles my case?+

Mordy Aryeh — directly. Strategy, court appearances, motion practice, and negotiation are not handed to a junior associate. Every accepted matter gets senior-level attention from intake through collection.

Where do you appear?+

Based in Cedarhurst, serving the Five Towns — Cedarhurst, Woodmere, Hewlett, Inwood & Lawrence — with regular appearances in Nassau County, Kings County (Brooklyn), Queens, Manhattan, and throughout downstate New York, plus New Jersey. Admitted in both states, so cross-border matters stay under one roof.

What should I have ready for the first call?+

The contract or invoices, any judgment or court papers, key correspondence, and whatever you know about the other side — banks, property, customers, insurance. Rough is fine; the first call is about fit, strategy, and an honest read on collectability. If you've been sued, bring everything you were served with, and note the date you received it.

Didn't find your answer? Twenty minutes on the phone answers it for your specific facts — free.
Aryeh Law Group PLLC

A commercial litigation and collections law firm in Cedarhurst, New York — serving Nassau County, Kings County, the Five Towns, New York City, and New Jersey.

THE FIRM
CONTACT
(646) 276-7070 WhatsApp mordy@aryehlawgroup.com LinkedIn 555 Willow Ave, Cedarhurst NY Mon – Fri: 9:00 am – 5:00 pm
SERVING
Nassau County · Kings County The Five Towns — Cedarhurst, Woodmere, Hewlett, Inwood & Lawrence New York City · New Jersey

© 2026 Aryeh Law Group PLLC. All rights reserved. Attorney Advertising. This website is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Contacting the firm does not create an attorney-client relationship. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Mordy Aryeh, Esq. is licensed in New York and New Jersey.